Fresh drops and pop-up dates land on Instagram first. Join the Drop List for first dibs.
← The Journal
October 9, 2026 · Guides

How to Build the Perfect Doughnut Box

By Doughnut Grl

How to Build the Perfect Doughnut Box

A great doughnut box is a little like a great playlist. A few crowd pleasers, one wild card and nothing anyone skips.

We pack a lot of boxes, so here is the formula we always come back to.

1. Pick your size

A half dozen is perfect for a small household, a date night or a "treat yourself" Saturday. A dozen is the move for the office, a birthday or any group where someone always wants a second one. When in doubt, go bigger. Nobody has ever complained about leftover doughnuts.

2. Start with the classics

Every box needs a couple of easy wins: a simple glazed or a rich chocolate. These are the doughnuts that make kids, grandparents and picky eaters happy.

Creme brulee and s'mores doughnuts on a cooling rack

3. Add a fan favorite

Next, grab something with a little drama. Our crème brûlée has a crackly torched top, and the s'mores is basically a campfire in doughnut form. These are the ones people take pictures of before the first bite.

4. Throw in a wild card

Every box deserves one flavor nobody would have picked on their own, like strawberry matcha or whatever is on the seasonal menu. It is almost always the one people talk about later.

5. Let us choose

Can't decide? Pick Baker's Choice when you order and we will build the box for you with the freshest flavors of the day.

A summer Doughnut Grl box with a s'mores doughnut

Pro tips

  • Order at least 3 days ahead so we can bake your box fresh the morning of pickup.
  • Doughnuts are best the day you get them. Enjoy them fast (that part is easy).
  • Feeding a crowd? Our catering page has everything you need.

Ready to build yours?

Order a Box →
Keep reading